
Choosing a recruitment agency is an important business decision. The right agency can help you attract talented people who make a real difference to your organisation, they can reduce time in your hiring process, they can attract talent you wouldn’t normally have access to, and they can also bring confidentiality when required.
Having worked in recruitment since 2004, we believe the best way to help make your decision is to ask the right questions.
1. How will you promote my business to potential candidates?
This is the first question I would ask.
A recruitment agency isn’t simply selling a vacancy; it is representing your business to people who may never have heard of you. If the recruiter doesn’t understand what makes your organisation attractive, how can they convince someone to join?
A good recruiter should understand your business, its products or services, its growth plans and what makes it different from competitors.
Ask them:
If the recruiter can only talk about advertising the vacancy and searching a database, you should question how effectively they will represent your business.
2. How will you assess candidates before recommending them?
Receiving a pile of CVs isn’t the same as receiving a shortlist of suitable candidates.
A good recruiter should interview candidates and establish their relevant experience, salary expectations, reasons for moving, location, availability and genuine interest in the opportunity. Ask the agency how it screens candidates and what checks it carries out before recommending someone for interview.
The objective is to save your hiring managers time by presenting candidates who have been properly assessed, rather than leaving you to establish the basics yourself.
The number of CVs submitted is not a measure of recruitment quality. The quality of the assessment is what matters.
3. Should you choose a large or small recruitment agency?
Many companies assume a large agency will deliver better results because it has more resources and a bigger candidate database.
However, size doesn’t guarantee service.
Large agencies can have strict performance targets and extensive client portfolios. While they may offer considerable resources, individual clients can sometimes struggle to get the attention their assignments deserve.
Smaller agencies often rely heavily on repeat business and referrals. Delivering for one client can lead to long-term relationships and recommendations to other businesses.
Neither size guarantees quality. What matters is whether the agency listens, understands your requirements and uses its resources effectively.
Ask:
Even the largest candidate database is of little value if the recruiter doesn’t listen to you.
4. Can you provide a reference from a recent client?
This is one of the most valuable questions you can ask.
Ask the agency to introduce you to a recent client who is willing to provide a reference. A satisfied client can tell you far more about the actual service than an agency’s sales presentation.
Ask whether the agency understood the brief, communicated effectively, assessed candidates properly and delivered on its promises.
No one knows how good your service is better than a happy client. Previous clients can become your best salespeople, so look for an agency with relationships it is proud to stand behind.
5. Will this be a two-way relationship?
Ultimately, the best recruitment relationships are partnerships, not transactions.
The more both sides invest, the more they are likely to get out of the relationship. Your recruiter needs a clear brief, honest feedback and timely decisions. In return, you should expect communication, attention to detail and a willingness to challenge you when necessary.
You should feel comfortable offering both criticism and compliments. Feedback helps the relationship improve and ensures that expectations remain clear.
One thing you shouldn’t have to do repeatedly is explain the same requirements to your recruiter. If you constantly have to repeat yourself, it can indicate a lack of care or attention.
A good recruiter listens, remembers what matters to your business and applies that understanding throughout the assignment.
Choosing the right recruitment agency
Before appointing a recruitment agency, ask yourself:
Having worked in recruitment since 2004, my advice is to choose an agency based on the quality of the relationship and its ability to deliver.
A good recruitment agency should make your life easier, represent your business professionally and help you make the right hiring decisions.
Choose a recruitment partner who sees your business as a relationship worth investing in, rather than just another vacancy to fill.